Updated:
Frequently asked questions
Questions that come up most often when a hospital considers medical AI. Select a question to see the answer.
Is AI software that a hospital buys a medical device in Singapore?
It can be. HSA’s guidelines apply to software whose intended use meets the definition of a medical device under the Health Products Act 2007, which includes software intended to investigate, detect, diagnose, monitor, treat or manage a medical condition. GL-04-R4 says Class B, C and D software medical devices require product registration. Ask the vendor in writing whether it treats the product as a medical device and why.
Source: isomer-user-content.by.gov.sg (Opens in a new tab) / isomer-user-content.by.gov.sg (Opens in a new tab)
What should a hospital’s AI governance look like?
The Ministry of Health’s AIHGle 2.0 recommends a governance platform that assesses and approves AI solutions, keeps a registry of every deployed solution with its risk classification, gives guidance on safe deployment and checks cybersecurity and data protection. It also recommends keeping three functions distinct: governance, day-to-day implementation and monitoring, and compliance audit.
Can an AI tool make clinical decisions on its own?
For clinical use, AIHGle 2.0 says deployers should not deploy AI solutions that make clinical decisions independently without a human making the final decision, and that healthcare professionals remain in charge of patient care outcomes.
What testing should we do before going live?
AIHGle 2.0 says the implementing organisation usually tests and validates the tool in its own context and workflows, may run a pilot with a smaller patient population for higher-risk solutions, and should measure clinical outcomes as well as algorithm performance.
Does a vendor have to tell HSA when it changes a registered AI model?
GL-04-R4 says a change notification is required for any change made to a registered machine-learning-enabled medical device. HSA’s optional Change Management Program lets a manufacturer have anticipated pre-specified changes approved in advance.
Source: isomer-user-content.by.gov.sg (Opens in a new tab) / isomer-user-content.by.gov.sg (Opens in a new tab)
How fast must we report a personal data breach?
According to the PDPC’s guide (revised 15 March 2021), assess within 30 calendar days whether the breach is notifiable and notify the PDPC within 3 calendar days after determining that it is. A breach involving the personal data of 500 or more individuals is of significant scale.
Source: pdpc.gov.sg (Opens in a new tab)
Which authorities do we report AI incidents to?
AIHGle 2.0 names the PDPC for data-related incidents, HSA for adverse events from the use of medical devices, and the Cyber Security Agency of Singapore for critical cybersecurity incidents, in addition to internal reporting.
What does the Ministry of Health say about generative AI?
AIHGle 2.0 names four amplified risks: hallucination, undesirable content, data disclosure and vulnerability to adversarial prompts. It says deployers should design workflows that support fact-checking, train professionals on responsible use, support patient communication and label AI-generated content where possible.
Regulation changes, so for important decisions check the primary source linked in each answer.